The Best Hitter in Pirate History? You might not like this.

Pirate history is renowned for its excellent hitters. The names, for the most part, are familiar. But one of the most overlooked – and even forgotten – may have been the best of them all.

Here’s a comparison of his Pirate numbers with those of Andrew McCutchen:

The Great Unknown  /   McCutchen

PA:    3,141  /   3,171

BA:   .308    /   .296

OBP: .426   /    .380

SLG:  .591   /    .489

OPS:  1.017 /   .869

HR:  165      /    103

BB%: 16.7% /   11.4%

K%:   10.9% /   16.7%

It isn’t close.

And it gets better.

Here are his numbers compared to those of Hall-of-Famer Paul Waner:

The Great Unknown  /  Paul Waner

PA:    3,141 / 9,532

BA:   .308   / .340

OBP: .426   / .407

SLG:  .591  /  .490

OPS:  1.017 /  .897

HR:     165   / 109

BB%:  16.7% /  9.5%

K%:   10.9% /   3.4%

Yes. It is possible that the teams of the Pirates lost generation had the best hitter in the 131 year history of the Pittsburgh Baseball Club.

Brian Giles.

Here are the Pirates all-time OPS leaders:

1. Brian Giles 1.018
2. Ralph Kiner .971
3. Jake Stenzel .958
4. Kiki Cuyler .912
5. George Grantham .901
6. Paul Waner .896
7. Jason Bay .890
8. Willie Stargell .889
9. Arky Vaughan .887
10. Barry Bonds .883

* Table from

But OPS only measures on-base percentage and slugging percentage – and there is more to hitting productivity than those two statistics.

Some may also contend that Giles numbers are inflated by the high-scoring era in which he played.

Well, there are sabermetrics to account for those factors. Runs Created measures a player’s total hitting performance. And weighted Runs Created Plus (wRC+) converts Runs Created into a stat that also measures players against the league averages for the years in which they played.

(League average for wRC+ is 100 and each point above or below 100 represents the percentage by which the player was better or worse than league average.)

Here are the Pirates all-time leaders in wRC+:

1. Brian Giles  156

2. Ralph Kiner  154

3.  Honus Wagner  151

4.  Willie Stargell  145

4.  Barry Bonds  145

6. Arky Vaughan  144

7.  Jake Stenzel  140

8.  Andrew McCutchen  139

9.  Paul Waner  138

10.  Kiki Cuyler  137

10.  Richie Zisk  137

Some may suggest that Giles stats are better than those of some other great Pirate hitters because he played in PNC Park, which (though it mildly favors pitchers) is a better hitters’ park than Forbes Field was. That can be addressed by a statistic called Adjusted OPS Plus. It modifies OPS according to ballpark and measures players against the league averages during the years in which they played.
Here are the Pirates all time leaders in Adjusted OPS Plus:
Rank Player Adjusted OPS+ PA
1. Brian Giles 158 3114
2. Ralph Kiner 157 4732
3. Honus Wagner 154 10220
4. Barry Bonds 147 4255
Willie Stargell 147 9027
Jake Stenzel 147 1987
7. Arky Vaughan 141 6182
8. Andrew McCutchen 139 3171
9. Richie Zisk 137 2240
10. Fred Carroll 136 2518
Fred Clarke 136 6368
Mike Smith 136 3443
Paul Waner 136 9536
* Table from
Another protest may be that Giles had significantly fewer plate appearances as a Pirate than did some of the teams’ other great hitters. However, while it is true that Giles’ Pirate career was shorter than those of Stargell, Kiner, Waner, and Wagner, his 3,174 plate appearances is not a small sample size – and he did play five seasons with the Pirates.
Brian Giles may or may not be the best Pirate hitter of all time, but any discussion of the issue that does not intensely consider Giles is a failed debate. Regardless of Giles ranking in team history, his seasons cannot be ignored. They were truly great.
And National League pitchers knew that Brian Giles was one of the best hitters they had ever seen. They walked him 135 times in 2002.


170 thoughts on “The Best Hitter in Pirate History? You might not like this.

  1. No doubt Giles was a terrific hitter. Not sure it an apples to apples comparison though between other Pirate greats. Giles spent only his prime years ages 28-32 in Pittsburgh. McCutchen is just entering his prime now. Bonds was gone before he really got into his prime. Even catching just the beginning of his prime, Bonds had a 154 wRC+ in his final 5 years as a Pirate. Those were his age 23-27 seasons. Stargell and Wagner played really long careers with the Pirates. Some of those seasons towards the end of their careers pull down their overall numbers. Wagner’s wRC+ during his age 28-32 seasons was 164. Extend it out even further from 1902-1909 and Wagner had a wRC+ of 171 during that period. Stargell had a 6 season stretch from 1969-1974 in which he posted a wRC+ of 162.

  2. SB

    Nice piece. You’re right. I don’t like it. Rooted for the Bucs and Giles and Brian was a bright spot in a dark period for the Pirates. My only pause is that I believe Brian Giles was juicing.

    I’m not sure if his numbers took dramatic turns over time. He was remarkably consistent and he WAS in his prime during his time with the Bucs. And one doesn’t like to find players guilty by suspicion. But I’m suspicious of Brian Giles.


    • Many have the same suspicions. That era of the game is forever tainted. I have been dealing with the steroids/stats issue by assuming an impact only if a player tested positive. But we will never really know.

      Hidden Vigorish makes a good point about Giles’ Pirate career numbers getting a boost because all of Giles time with the Pirates was in the prime of his career,

  3. Pingback: Trackback

  4. Pingback:

  5. Pingback: Trackback

  6. Pingback: Trackback

  7. Pingback: here

  8. Pingback: Trackback

  9. Pingback: Grand Theft Auto: Vice City cheats

  10. Pingback: Trackback

  11. Pingback: Trackback

  12. Pingback: Trackback

  13. Pingback: Trackback

  14. Pingback: Trackback

  15. Pingback: Trackback

  16. Pingback: Trackback

  17. Pingback: Trackback

  18. Pingback: Trackback

  19. Pingback: Trackback

  20. Pingback: Trackback

  21. Pingback:

  22. Pingback: Trackback

  23. Pingback: max garcinia cambogia extract

  24. Pingback: testosterone pills that work

  25. Pingback: full report Phoenix DUI attorneys

  26. Pingback: Visit Website Tempe DUI lawyers

  27. Pingback: lening simulator

  28. Pingback: glucogen

  29. Pingback: Cleaning Supplies

  30. Pingback: paintless dent repair training

  31. Pingback: paintless dent removal training

  32. Pingback: paintless dent repair training

  33. Pingback: pure garcinia side effects

  34. Pingback: J Gateway

  35. Pingback: paintless dent repair tools

  36. Pingback: paintless dent repair training by

  37. Pingback: discount membership

  38. Pingback: website

  39. Pingback: ถ่ายรูปรับปริญญา

  40. Pingback: commonwealth tower condo queenstown

  41. Pingback: Love Letters For Him

  42. Pingback: หางานช่างภาพอิสระ

  43. Pingback: water vapor cigarette reviews

  44. Pingback: they can do it here

  45. Pingback: Love Letters For Her

  46. Pingback:

  47. Pingback: new apartment

  48. Pingback: cool site

  49. Pingback: visit this site

  50. Pingback:

  51. Pingback:

  52. Pingback: rachael ray diet garcinia

  53. Pingback: see more

  54. Pingback: kosiarka ręczna

  55. Pingback: Trackback

  56. Pingback: loans with no credit check

  57. Pingback: e cigarettes starter kit

  58. Pingback: transunion free credit score

  59. Pingback:

  60. Pingback: african art prints

  61. Pingback: site

  62. Pingback: รับปริญญา

  63. Pingback: Kids

  64. Pingback: pure cambogia garcinia dr oz

  65. Pingback: muscle rev xtreme free trial

  66. Pingback: garcinia cambogia 60 hca gnc

  67. Pingback: see details

  68. Pingback: boutique hotels cape town

  69. Pingback: campaign strategy

  70. Pingback: informacion

  71. Pingback: home page

  72. Pingback: Soccer IQ

  73. Pingback: web hosting service

  74. Pingback: garcinia extract

  75. Pingback: Hot Stamping Foil Roll Manufacturers Suppliers

  76. Pingback: best fat burners for men

  77. Pingback: weight loss diets for women

  78. Pingback: optymalizacja stron

  79. Pingback: free triple credit report

  80. Pingback: 3 credit scores

  81. Pingback: weight loss dr oz

  82. Pingback: rower

  83. Pingback: cambogia garcinia reviews

  84. Pingback: fda approved diet pill

  85. Pingback: 3 credit scores

  86. Pingback: LED signs

  87. Pingback: intruder alarm maintenance company inlondon

  88. Pingback: Minneapolis SEO Company

  89. Pingback: Digital Signage

  90. Pingback: mejores articulos

  91. Pingback: Austin SEO Consultant

  92. Pingback: access control

  93. Pingback: home security systems company in london

  94. Pingback: wireless intruder alarms installation in london

  95. Pingback: depannage plombier paris

  96. Pingback: cambogia garcinia side effects

  97. Pingback:

  98. Pingback: how to get rid of cellulite

  99. Pingback:

  100. Pingback:

  101. Pingback: Trackback

  102. Pingback: deer antler spray free trial

  103. Pingback: paintless dent repair training

  104. Pingback: plumber service

  105. Pingback: como controlar la eyaculación precoz

  106. Pingback: Zippered Included Cloud9 Memory Foam B001830HHE

  107. Pingback: remodeling contractors atlanta

  108. Pingback: Tiddliwinks Madagascar Shower Curtain Brown B002BFNFG8

  109. Pingback: play video

  110. Pingback: dr oz weight loss

  111. Pingback: modnaja odezhda

  112. Pingback: kitchen remodeling marietta ga

  113. Pingback: onlain magazin bashmag

  114. Pingback: on-line magazin boutique ru

  115. Pingback: modnaja odezhda

  116. Pingback: ElitePeoples.RU

  117. Pingback: ElitePeoples.RU

  118. Pingback: blog de noticias

  119. Pingback: home improvement atlanta ga

  120. Pingback: zdrowa dieta

  121. Pingback: Air Duct Cleaning in Vallejo

  122. Pingback: knives atrd01 armegeddon micarta handles b007s7r3nu 5809

  123. Pingback: macross display stand for valkyrie b0007lkv4m 6041

  124. Pingback: polk audio tsx 220b bookshelf b00chhcd0e 5163

  125. Pingback: kidkraft pirate toddler bed b00hqhy7ja 4771

  126. Pingback: where to buy percussion caps

  127. Pingback: Джемпер EDC by Esprit

  128. Pingback: Ботинки Patrol

  129. Pingback: Топ Blend

  130. Pingback: Пуховик Puma

  131. Pingback: Шапка Fete

  132. Pingback: Сумка Napapijri

  133. Pingback: Лонгслив Bikkembergs

  134. Pingback: Джинсы Frankie B

  135. Pingback: gde v permi kupit podvesnaja lyustra 540

  136. Pingback: bauanleitung puppenhaus

  137. Pingback: kostyumyi sochi 2014

  138. Pingback: potencja

  139. Pingback: Where to buy center

  140. Pingback: Where can i buy

  141. Pingback: Where can i buy

  142. Pingback: Where can i buy

  143. Pingback: Where can i buy

  144. Pingback: 600 enterprise hard drive wd6001bkhg b0081tyi3c 629

  145. Pingback: hp flexible thin client t610 b007ur2jn2 3793

  146. Pingback: nissan keyless clicker programming discount b0052umnfi 4054

  147. Pingback: black horse loan

  148. Pingback: montel williams loans online

  149. Pingback: cashback payday advance rancho cucamonga

  150. Pingback: ez payday loan

  151. Pingback: Trackback

  152. Pingback: how to consolidate bills

  153. Pingback: bad credit mortage loans

  154. Pingback: payday loans wisconsin lenders only

  155. Pingback: Trackback

  156. Pingback: website

  157. Pingback: where can i find garcinia cambogia extract

  158. Pingback: Trackback

  159. Pingback: a handy loan

  160. Pingback: Trackback

  161. Pingback: Trackback

  162. Pingback: Blog

  163. Pingback: Message...

  164. Pingback: Footprint

  165. Pingback: Tech

  166. Pingback: {amoxil oral drops dosage|amoxil stomach upset|can you drink on amoxil|amoxil medicinenet|recommended dosage for amoxil|buy amoxil online canada|classification of amoxil}

  167. Pingback: Health

  168. Pingback: Finance

  169. Pingback: Liberty

Leave a Reply