How Kendrys Morales Could Make Sense for Pirates

On January 25, Nick Cafardo of the Boson Globe wrote that if the Pirates don’t sign A.J. Burnett, they will use the money that had been reserved for Burnett to acquire an “everyday” first-baseman.

I responded to Cafardo’s report with a post (link) in which I quickly dismissed free agent Kendrys Morales as a possible “everyday” first-baseman for the Pirates. My reasons included the facts that Morales has only played 59 games at 1B since breaking his leg in 2010 and that the Pirates would have to surrender their 2014 first round draft choice as compensation for signing Morales. But Cafardo is now reporting that there is mutual interest between the Pirates and Morales, so, I am willing to revisit the possibility.

The First Round Draft Choice

I had felt that having to give up their first-round choice would keep the Pirates from even considering the possibility of signing Morales. And I believed that it would be a mistake for the Pirates to surrender that draft choice. But the Pirates are selecting 25th this year. In 2012, they traded for Gaby Sanchez and, in exchange, they gave the 35th pick in the 2013 draft to the Miami Marlins.

Morales could be worth the 25th pick in the first round of the 2014 draft.


Morales’ Defense

Baseball Prospectus 2014 says, “Morales might have been a good defender once, but the injury hindered him in the field.” And the statistics support that evaluation. Morales was once a pretty good defensive first-baseman.

In Morales’ last full season at 1B, 2009, he had a +5.6 UZR and was 8 defensive runs saved (drs) above average in 152 games. In 51 games at first-base in 2010 – prior to breaking his leg – Morales had a +4.0 UZR and a +3 drs.

But a broken leg changes things – especially one that requires surgery and an 18 month recovery.

In 28 games at 1B in 2012, Morales was -1 drs. That doesn’t sound bad, but over the course of a full season it equates to -5 drs and would cost his team about 0.5 wins. On the other hand, his 2012 UZR was a very good +2.3.

In 2013, however, all of the defensive metrics showed Morales as below average. In just 31 games, his UZR was -1.2, his drs was -2, and Baseball Prospectus had him at 1.3 Fielding Runs Below Average. Over a full season, that would put Morales somewhere between 6 and 9 runs below average.

Projection as Pirate

Plate Appearances: 440

BB%: 6.8%

K%:  16.2%

Batting Average:  .280

On-Base Percentage:  .334

Slugging Percentage:  .462

OPS:  .796

HR:  16

WAR: 0.9

A .796 OPS would be a vast upgrade on the .708 OPS that Garrett Jones gave the Pirates in 2013, but Morales’ below average defense and baserunning drags his overall value down to a 0.9 WAR.

Contract and Compensation

Morales turned down Seattle’s $14.1 million qualifying offer. That was a mistake.

Morales’ WAR-based Free Agent Value is $8.1 million. But the Pirates should not be willing to go that high for him. His projected 0.9 WAR is only worth about $4.8 million and the Pirates would also be paying the substantial price of giving up their 2014 first-round draft pick.

First round draft choices are precious to the Pirates. They need to keep acquiring and developing top prospects if they want to have a good shot at the playoffs every year, rather than trying to take advantage of a “window of contention” before they have to tear down and rebuild. But Huntington did trade the 35th pick in the 2013 draft to the Marlins for Gaby Sanchez. So, it is not out of the question that he would trade the 25th pick in the 2014 draft for Kendrys Morales.

Here’s how signing Morales and surrendering the pick could make sense.

The Pirates must get a big bargain on the contract and they must be able to use Morales to bring back prospects.

Morales WAR-based value is $8.1 million. His projected value is $4.8 million. I think the Pirates should be willing to go to $5 million, but they also have to get Morales for more than one season.

My plan would be to offer Morales a back-loaded, two-year contract with a team option for a third year. It would be something like $4 million for 2014, $8 million for 2015, and a $12 million option for 2016.

The Pirates would have Morales at a bargain rate for 2014 and could trade him for prospects after the season.

Will there be teams willing to trade prospects for a 1B with a .796 OPS and an $8 million contract? The Rockies recently signed Justin Morneau (.734 OPS) for 2 years and $12.5 million and the Marlins signed Garrett Jones and his .708 OPS for 2 years and $7.75 million.

This plan could potentially work out better in the long-run, as well as in 2014, than keeping the first round pick. The Pirates are no longer selecting at the top of the draft. Their excellent 2013 means that they will be picking 25th in the first round this year. It’s not unlikely that a prospect acquired in return for Morales could end up having a better career than the 25th pick in the draft.

Or, rather than going through all of that trouble, the Pirates could just keep the draft choice and go with Andrew Lambo at 1B. Or trade Nick Kingham for Ike Davis. But Eric Chavez was the left-handed 1B option whom I really wanted.





414 thoughts on “How Kendrys Morales Could Make Sense for Pirates

  1. I was working on a similar post. I figure he needs at least $14.5 guaranteed or he’ll just wait until after the draft. I’d go for 2 years. $6 mill in the first $8.5 in the second. Sweeten it with a couple million more in playing time incentives. If he can play nearly everyday the value will be there. Part of the reason the WAR is suppressed is because he was mostly a DH. Even playing subpar defensively at 1B would add WAR value over strictly being a DH. If he can’t handle the field you move him to an American League team for a bucket of balls just to unload the salary.

    • It’s good to see that somebody whose opinion I respect is thinking along the same lines. I wasn’t sure that I was not off the deep end with this. You may be right about the $14.5 million guarantee to get Morales past the sting of turning down the qualifying offer. But that should still be a manageable amount.

  2. I wouldn’t want Morales even at minimum wage, just because I value the pick more than him (and even tho the 25th pick hasn’t historically ‘brought home’ too many lumanaries).


  3. Pingback: Putting Burnett’s $12 million to Good Use | SABER BUCS

  4. Pingback: Pirates Must Still be Patient with 1B Market | SABER BUCS

  5. Pingback: Garfield Abreau

  6. Pingback: Bulah Vanis

  7. Pingback: Norwegia

  8. Pingback: Grand Theft Auto: Vice City cheats

  9. Pingback: Trackback

  10. Pingback: Trackback

  11. Pingback: Trackback

  12. Pingback: Trackback

  13. Pingback: Trackback

  14. Pingback: Trackback

  15. Pingback: Trackback

  16. Pingback: Trackback

  17. Pingback: Trackback

  18. Pingback: Trackback

  19. Pingback: Trackback

  20. Pingback: Trackback

  21. Pingback: cheap disney world vacation packages

  22. Pingback: Trackback

  23. Pingback: Trackback

  24. Pingback: Dentist IL

  25. Pingback: max garcinia cambogia extract

  26. Pingback: best testosterone booster

  27. Pingback: Trackback

  28. Pingback: glucogen

  29. Pingback: lenen berekenen

  30. Pingback: paintless dent removal training

  31. Pingback: paintless dent repair training

  32. Pingback: muscle rev x ingredients

  33. Pingback: Freehold Condo

  34. Pingback: paintless dent repair training

  35. Pingback: pdr tool sets

  36. Pingback: paintless dent repair training by

  37. Pingback: travel club

  38. Pingback: Love Letters For Him

  39. Pingback: commonwealth towers sg

  40. Pingback:

  41. Pingback: Love Letters For Her

  42. Pingback: ถ่ายรูป

  43. Pingback: vapor e cigarettes

  44. Pingback: click here

  45. Pingback: Discover a gold ira protectors

  46. Pingback: men secrets

  47. Pingback:

  48. Pingback: the ex factor guides

  49. Pingback:

  50. Pingback: rachael ray weight loss garcinia cambogia

  51. Pingback: credit report gov

  52. Pingback: Trackback

  53. Pingback: kosiarki

  54. Pingback: long term installment loans

  55. Pingback: interesting and professional packaging dvd

  56. Pingback: e cigarette dangers 2014

  57. Pingback: annual free credit score

  58. Pingback:

  59. Pingback: OTC Stocks

  60. Pingback: african decorations

  61. Pingback: garcinia cambogia for weight loss gnc

  62. Pingback: Home

  63. Pingback: where to buy garcinia cambogia extract gnc

  64. Pingback: herbal sleeping pills

  65. Pingback: url man

  66. Pingback: angular cheilitis

  67. Pingback: cheap accommodation

  68. Pingback: pauly 888

  69. Pingback: Strategic Campaigns Inc Kansas City

  70. Pingback: articulo

  71. Pingback: Soccer IQ

  72. Pingback: japan luxury hotels

  73. Pingback: Charles

  74. Pingback: join big idea mastermind

  75. Pingback: free netflix accounts

  76. Pingback: big idea mastermind review

  77. Pingback: ช่างภาพรับปริญญา

  78. Pingback: advertising web design

  79. Pingback:

  80. Pingback: Tally ERP POS Integration with Ecommerce

  81. Pingback: jawatan kosong

  82. Pingback: no deposit bonus codes 2014

  83. Pingback: low fat diet

  84. Pingback: installment loans online no credit check

  85. Pingback: black dating site

  86. Pingback: vicks vapor rub and nail fungus

  87. Pingback: Conquistare un uomo

  88. Pingback: eiaculazioni precoce rimedi

  89. Pingback: eiaculazioni precoce rimedi

  90. Pingback: eiaculazioni precoce rimedi

  91. Pingback: Unlock iPhone Israel

  92. Pingback: search engine submission tools

  93. Pingback: pozycjonowanie stron internetowych

  94. Pingback: electric cigarette sample

  95. Pingback: ขนมกลีบลำดวน

  96. Pingback: consumer fraud

  97. Pingback: web hosts reviews

  98. Pingback: identity theft

  99. Pingback: Cedar-Rapids real estate videos

  100. Pingback: 3 credit scores

  101. Pingback: (PMI Certification

  102. Pingback: Great Music

  103. Pingback: finance fundation

  104. Pingback: cheapoair promo code

  105. Pingback: dr oz diet

  106. Pingback: cheapoair promo code

  107. Pingback: kupujemy rower

  108. Pingback:

  109. Pingback: food safety

  110. Pingback: cheapoair promo codes

  111. Pingback: samsung universe

  112. Pingback: get local

  113. Pingback: plural design

  114. Pingback: hyundai hybryd

  115. Pingback: what to eat to have healthy hair

  116. Pingback: pure garcinia

  117. Pingback: skinny diet pills

  118. Pingback: web hosting web

  119. Pingback: dr oz weight loss garcinia

  120. Pingback: Garcinia Cambogia

  121. Pingback: clever electric

  122. Pingback: casino chips for sale ebay

  123. Pingback: For Katy Air Conditioning visit

  124. Pingback: UK power cord

  125. Pingback: cheapoair promo code

  126. Pingback: houston roofing contractors

  127. Pingback: Construction Signs

  128. Pingback: chad conley bail bonds

  129. Pingback: improve credit score

  130. Pingback: moneys to nevil

  131. Pingback: new internet marketing

  132. Pingback: cheapoair promo code

  133. Pingback: home security system company

  134. Pingback: SEO Minneapolis Tips

  135. Pingback: cheapoair coupom

  136. Pingback: Dallas

  137. Pingback: cheapoair discount code

  138. Pingback: best marketer in san diego

  139. Pingback: i love you

  140. Pingback: entry system installation london

  141. Pingback: buy soundcloud likes

  142. Pingback: SEO Company Austin

  143. Pingback: blog

  144. Pingback: Garcinia Cambogia

  145. Pingback: meadville auto insurance

  146. Pingback: painting contractors katy tx

  147. Pingback:

  148. Pingback: home security installation company london

  149. Pingback: party rentals northridge

  150. Pingback: this article

  151. Pingback: artificial turf malibu

  152. Pingback: locksmith

  153. Pingback: best seo software

  154. Pingback: byggbolag gavle

  155. Pingback: Lunatik promo code

  156. Pingback: converting vhs to digital

  157. Pingback: Lunatik coupon code

  158. Pingback: Lunatik discount

  159. Pingback: how to avoid premature ejaculation naturally

  160. Pingback: Lunatik coupons

  161. Pingback: Lunatik promo code

  162. Pingback: Lunatik promo codes

  163. Pingback: Lunatik coupons

  164. Pingback: this website

  165. Pingback: I thought about this

  166. Pingback: Lunatik discount code

  167. Pingback:

  168. Pingback: premature ejaculation in dreams

  169. Pingback: garcinia cambogia

  170. Pingback: lunatik coupon code

  171. Pingback:

  172. Pingback: how to reduce cellulite on your thighs

  173. Pingback:

  174. Pingback: Lunatik promo

  175. Pingback: 2014 FIFA World Cup Highlights Video Brazil

  176. Pingback: paintless dent repair training

  177. Pingback: deer antler spray reviews bodybuilding

  178. Pingback:

  179. Pingback: vik sofia

  180. Pingback: Lunatik promo code

  181. Pingback: Barefoot Dream Bamboo Adult Throw B005ADEOK4

  182. Pingback: replacing boat floor long beach

  183. Pingback: Danze D451289DN Eight Inch Showerhead Distressed B0012QQTA6

  184. Pingback: JR Products 81665 Shower Curtain B002UCAEWA

  185. Pingback: modnaja odezhda

  186. Pingback: Harga Timbangan Digital

  187. Pingback: modnaja odezhda

  188. Pingback: onlain magazin bashmag

  189. Pingback: on-line magazin boutique ru

  190. Pingback: custom home builders atlanta

  191. Pingback: ElitePeoples.RU

  192. Pingback: ElitePeoples.RU

  193. Pingback: Local SEO in Dallas

  194. Pingback: boat interior cushions upholstery

  195. Pingback: home remodeling roswell ga

  196. Pingback: Home-based business ideas

  197. Pingback: stress free

  198. Pingback: porter cable pc14ctsd 14 inch chop open b004x1pau2 9086

  199. Pingback: mclane 17 ph 7 17 inch 7 blade front throw b001sarmi4 5494

  200. Pingback: woll titanium quart stockpot vented b002zhbn8e 7098

  201. Pingback: oceanside deck contractor

  202. Pingback: kraus gv 580 copper illusion vessel b004ha3gl4 3349

  203. Pingback: white frost privacy window adhesive b00cdo36ts 3879

  204. Pingback: Slotomania Free Coins Iphone

  205. Pingback: xscorpion qtr17 rca triple shielding b00atzhfsg 1608

  206. Pingback: the sharper image select a temp stainless b004z0zy2a 4212

  207. Pingback: leick furniture 8207 mission impeccable b0034ezfbs 1634

  208. Pingback: where to buy roll caps

  209. Pingback: overnight dogsitting in naples

  210. Pingback: coco palms singapore

  211. Pingback:

  212. Pingback: Джемпер Gas

  213. Pingback: Лонгслив Top Secret

  214. Pingback: Футболка Jack

  215. Pingback: Jual Timbangan

  216. Pingback: Джинсы F5

  217. Pingback: Джемпер Esprit

  218. Pingback: Туфли Casadei

  219. Pingback: Футболка Broadway

  220. Pingback: Кеды Guess

  221. Pingback: naples boarding

  222. Pingback: magazin gde kupit nakladnoi svetilnik germanika a3930ap 1go

  223. Pingback: siku schneepflug

  224. Pingback: porn movie

  225. Pingback: Matthew Mainen

  226. Pingback: search engine optimization blog

  227. Pingback: Diet pills

  228. Pingback: carpet muncher

  229. Pingback: Lunatik promo code

  230. Pingback: garcinia

  231. Pingback: 411-pain

  232. Pingback: bForex set-up

  233. Pingback: Dennis Hernandez

  234. Pingback: dht blocking shampoos

  235. Pingback: Tampa dennis hernandez

  236. Pingback: Dentistry

  237. Pingback: ottawa apartments

  238. Pingback: cam sex

  239. Pingback: cheapoair promo code

  240. Pingback: UVAMIS

  241. Pingback: iconic watches

  242. Pingback: Trackback

  243. Pingback: the watch source

  244. Pingback: escort in Antofagasta

  245. Pingback: Permaculture Activist

  246. Pingback: tabletki na potencje opinie

  247. Pingback: sztachety plastikowe

  248. Pingback: ogrodzenia

  249. Pingback: cheapoair promo code

  250. Pingback: galeria

  251. Pingback: Scammy School

  252. Pingback: cheapoair coupon code

  253. Pingback: cheapoair promo code

  254. Pingback: UIC Asian Computer Services Pte Ltd

  255. Pingback: naples boarding

  256. Pingback: naples pet kennel

  257. Pingback: brochure design devon

  258. Pingback: Cute Viagra boys suits

  259. Pingback: puahate owner

  260. Pingback: injustice gods among us hack

  261. Pingback: payday loans online

  262. Pingback: Parker

  263. Pingback: richma

  264. Pingback: hack

  265. Pingback: Garden Bridges

  266. Pingback: mold removal toronto

  267. Pingback: buy facebook likes cheap

  268. Pingback: antalyahomes

  269. Pingback: donate plasma

  270. Pingback: friv

  271. Pingback: Electric bicycle

  272. Pingback: Electric bicycle

  273. Pingback: obligacje

  274. Pingback: forex

  275. Pingback: best dui attorney harrisburg pa

  276. Pingback: SEO

  277. Pingback: 1/2 Poker

  278. Pingback: 1/2 Gambling general

  279. Pingback: christianaty types

  280. Pingback: hans christian andersen stories

  281. Pingback: hyundai accent manuals

  282. Pingback: stone grilling

  283. Pingback: cheap facebook likes

  284. Pingback: tantric methods last longer bed

  285. Pingback: Trackback

  286. Pingback: Neal Ewing

  287. Pingback: bollywood song lyrics

  288. Pingback: levitra

  289. Pingback: spray to make you last longer in bed

  290. Pingback: ejac

  291. Pingback: buy youtube views

  292. Pingback: SEO Singapore

  293. Pingback: Dental Website Design

  294. Pingback: moon bounce rental

  295. Pingback: dunk tank rent

  296. Pingback: Concurso seo

  297. Pingback: Toronto Freelance Web Design

  298. Pingback: portland bankruptcy attorney

  299. Pingback: erupter asic

  300. Pingback: bankruptcy attorney harrisburg pa

  301. Pingback: outlook email

  302. Pingback: seguro viagem usa

  303. Pingback: premature ejaculation solutions guide

  304. Pingback: free cheats

  305. Pingback: seguro viagem europa

  306. Pingback: rolety katowice

  307. Pingback: meble stylizowane

  308. Pingback: bielizna erotyczna

  309. Pingback: Ogloszenia Rzeszow

  310. Pingback: projekty domów

  311. Pingback: cheap viagra online uk next day delivery

  312. Pingback: PMP Certification)

  313. Pingback: android games hacks

  314. Pingback: cheapest canadian viagra

  315. Pingback: ahandyloan

  316. Pingback: Trackback

  317. Pingback: chinese herbal medicine viagra

  318. Pingback: free coins for slotomania

  319. Pingback: Trackback

  320. Pingback: iherb coupon code

  321. Pingback: android hack

  322. Pingback: browse this website

  323. Pingback: iherb coupon code

  324. Pingback: iherb coupon

  325. Pingback: timbangan digital harga

  326. Pingback: how to make music

  327. Pingback: drzwi zewnetrzne kielce

  328. Pingback: iherb coupon codes

  329. Pingback:

  330. Pingback: najlepsi bukmacherzy

  331. Pingback: pharmacie andorre cialis

  332. Pingback: Paket Pulau Tidung

  333. Pingback: Endermologia Rzeszów

  334. Pingback: Heavy Shooter

  335. Pingback: okna pcv siedlce

  336. Pingback: iherb discount code

  337. Pingback: iherb coupon

  338. Pingback: painful fail

  339. Pingback: VideoClip Leon y Violetta cantan Nuestro camino Buena Calidad HQ

  340. Pingback: syndrome wallpapers

  341. Pingback: permaculture

  342. Pingback: ansiedad síntomas

  343. Pingback: funniest commercials ever

  344. Pingback: Diindolylmethane

  345. Pingback: biggest trucks in the world

  346. Pingback: szkolenia sep

  347. Pingback: porady prawne katowice

  348. Pingback: fotograf slubny

  349. Pingback: domki drewniane

  350. Pingback: buy viagra

  351. Pingback: jasa desain

  352. Pingback: play free online games

  353. Pingback: - Katowice

  354. Pingback: raporty gps

  355. Pingback: drzwi przeciwpozarowe

  356. Pingback: action pool safety

  357. Pingback: Blog

  358. Pingback: buy cialis

  359. Pingback: Hosted PBX solution

  360. Pingback: cialis livraison 24h

  361. Pingback: buy facebook followers

  362. Pingback: deals

  363. Pingback: narozniki

  364. Pingback: handmade ceramic tiles

  365. Pingback: niwelator laserowy

  366. Pingback: pilule cialis

  367. Pingback: How to Get Free Xbox Live 2 Day Trial Codes

  368. Pingback: prix cialis 20mg

  369. Pingback: Camp

  370. Pingback: funny cat vines

  371. Pingback: seo

  372. Pingback: Baseball Fundraiser

  373. Pingback: movies on dvd

  374. Pingback: best commercial 2014

  375. Pingback: weight loss plan

  376. Pingback: cialis au canada

  377. Pingback: Dr Johan Vente

  378. Pingback: water ionizers

  379. Pingback: Start

  380. Pingback:

  381. Pingback: Best SEO Programs

  382. Pingback: add url

  383. Pingback: Health

  384. Pingback: best price services

  385. Pingback: radiator electric fans

  386. Pingback: tadalafil softabs

  387. Pingback: Finance

  388. Pingback: skup samochodów kielce

  389. Pingback: zamówienia publiczne

  390. Pingback: wyjazdy integracyjne dla firm

  391. Pingback: plyty betonowe

  392. Pingback: hurtownia odziezy tureckiej

  393. Pingback: tworzenie sklepów internetowych

  394. Pingback: male virility enhancers

  395. Pingback: kancelaria adwokacka Katowice

  396. Pingback: Biura rachunkowe Olsztyn

  397. Pingback: chwilówki online

  398. Pingback: Real

  399. Pingback: private labels skin care

  400. Pingback: Liberty

  401. Pingback: leenlife

  402. Pingback: kosmetyki mineralne

  403. Pingback: szkolenie

  404. Pingback: capture his heart review

  405. Pingback: Trading

  406. Pingback: cialis vrai

  407. Pingback: iherb coupon code

  408. Pingback: Kosmetyczka Krosno

  409. Pingback: Lamborghini Aventador spalanie

  410. Pingback: iherb coupon

  411. Pingback: water ionizers

Leave a Reply